For Every Repair Facility in the NYC Tristate

You fix the cars.
We handle the insurers.

Your ally in every settlement

Amity Appraisals handles the entire insurance claims process for facilities, including supplements, documentation, calls, and pushback, so you get paid fully and fairly for the work you actually do.

Licensed Claims Adjuster No recovery, no fee Entire claim managed, so your shop manager doesn't have to
Claim #โ€ฆ9260 ยท Front-Right Hit ยท Fender
Carrier's initial estimate$2,741.14
Supplement line items added+ 52 line items
Re-inspection handled byAmity
Calls made by your shop0
Final approved amount$10,154.82
Tap to open a real settlement PDF โ†—
We work with all insurance companies
GEICO State Farm Progressive Allstate Liberty Mutual Nationwide Travelers
Sound familiar?

The Claim Grind Is Eating Your Margins

The Lowball

The photo estimate comes in at half of what teardown reveals. You supplement. They stall, "re-inspect," and pay a fraction of what the repair really takes.

The Phone Tag

Hours on hold, three different adjusters, the same photos resubmitted twice. Meanwhile the car sits on your lift, burning a bay you could be billing.

The Free Labor

Every admin hour you or your estimator spends chasing a carrier is unbilled time, a hidden tax quietly applied to every single RO.

You didn't open a shop to become an insurance negotiator. That's what your ally is for.

What Amity Handles

Four Promises. End to End.

The same four commitments printed on the back of our card, delivered on every claim your shop sends us.

Negotiation

Licensed to defend and represent your shop with every insurance company: adjuster to adjuster, in carrier language, without backing down.

Documentation

Professional estimates and airtight recordkeeping that back your shop legally and make supplements hard to deny.

Compensation

Settlements secured in your shop's fairest interest, so you get paid what the work actually deserves.

Follow Up

Proactive handling and communication end to end. You always know where the claim stands without making a single call.

$0k+
Recovered for shops*
0%
Avg. supplement increase*
0 hrs
Returned per shop, weekly*
How It Works

We Carry the Claim. You Keep the Bays Moving.

1

Send Us the File

Text or upload the estimate, photos, and claim number to (917) 510-4350. Five minutes for your front desk, the last heavy lift you do.

2

We Build the Case

We review the teardown, document every missed operation and part, and prepare a supplement package carriers can't wave away.

3

We Fight for the Number

Every call, every re-inspection, and every objection is handled by your licensed representative.

4

You Get Paid Fairly

Approval comes through, the car rolls out, and you see exactly what was recovered. Then we do it again on the next one.

Try It: Move the Sliders

What's the Fight Costing Your Shop?

Rough numbers are fine. See what underpaid supplements and unbilled admin hours add up to in a year.

Estimated revenue at stake this year
$164,280
Underpaid supplements + unbilled admin time, annualized.
See What a Free Estimate Finds
The Case Files

Drag to See the Difference an Ally Makes

Slide the handle to compare where each claim started with where Amity finished it. Three real Amity files: a 2026 BMW M3 taken from a $2,741.14 offer to $10,154.82, a 2020 AMG GT C settled at $18,976.82, and a 2022 McLaren 720S moved from $44,286.75 to $67,412.40.

Case 01 ยท 2026 BMW M3 Competition ยท Front-Right Impact (bumper ยท fender ยท headlamp ยท wheel)

2026 BMW M3 Competition with front-right collision damage, Case 01 vehicle
Amity Final Settlement
Parts: OEM bumper, lamp, fender, wheel$5,956.86
Body & refinish labor: 34.9 hrs @ $65$2,268.50
Mechanical: 4.9 hrs @ $125$612.50
Glass labor$19.50
Paint & materials$591.00
Sales tax (net)$706.46
Net supplement recovered+$7,413.68
APPROVED$10,154.82
Paid in Full โœ“
Carrier Initial EstimateClaim #โ€ฆ9260-2
Bumper & fender: "repair only"-
R combination headlamp: omitted$0
Parts: wheel & misc.$1,339.00
Body labor: 10.0 hrs @ $55$550.00
Paint labor: 7.0 hrs @ $55$385.00
Mechanical & paint supplies$370.00
Sales tax$97.14
OFFERED$2,741.14
Lowball
โ€น โ€บ
BEFOREAFTER
Case 01 ยท the complete estimate PDFs ยท tap to open ยท identifiers redacted

Case 02 ยท 2020 Mercedes-AMG GT C ยท Front-Left Impact (bumper ยท headlamp ยท fender)

2020 Mercedes-AMG GT C with front-left collision damage, Case 02 vehicle
Amity Final Settlement
Parts: OEM, fully documented$11,885.75
Body labor: 20.2 hrs$1,212.00
Paint labor: 12.3 hrs$738.00
Paint supplies$467.40
Miscellaneous & other$1,555.00
+ Supplement: teardown & rate adj.$1,800.00
Sales & county tax$1,318.67
APPROVED$18,976.82
Paid in Full โœ“
Damage AssessmentClaim #โ€ฆ1027-01
Front bumper, grilles & trim$5,174.50
Impact bar, supports & mounts$1,548.00
LT headlamp assembly$1,206.25
LT fender (ALU) & liner$2,626.00
Radiator support (front shield)$304.00
Cooling: cooler & ducts$1,012.00
Pre-repair scan$15.00
OFFERED$11,885.75
Missed Damage
โ€น โ€บ
BEFOREAFTER

Case 03 ยท 2022 McLaren 720S ยท Left-Rear Impact (quarter panel ยท turbo ยท intercooler ยท suspension)

2022 McLaren 720S with left-rear collision damage, Case 03 vehicle
Amity Final Settlement
New RR quarter panel & body panels$12,300.00
Turbo, intercooler, intakes & suspension (OEM)$31,150.00
Body & structural labor (specialty rate)$12,400.00
Mechanical labor (rear-engine access)$6,850.00
Paint & materials$2,100.00
Sales tax$2,612.40
Net supplement recovered+$23,125.65
APPROVED$67,412.40
Paid in Full โœ“
Carrier Initial EstimateSpecialty Vehicle
Rear internals & structural: omitted$0
Specialty labor: standard rate applied-
RR quarter panel R&R & body panels$16,900.00
Remaining parts (book pricing)$14,850.00
Body & paint labor (standard rate)$8,420.00
Mechanical$1,730.25
Materials, misc. & tax$2,386.50
OFFERED$44,286.75
Underestimated
โ€น โ€บ
BEFOREAFTER

Drag the handle left and right; works with touch on mobile too.

Shops We've Fought For

Real Files. Real Numbers.

โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

"Supplements that used to take 3 weeks of arguing now clear in days, and the checks got bigger. Less headache so we can put time into everything else."

Shop ManagerQueens, NY
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

"Amity caught required labor operations we'd stopped even fighting for. It's like adding a claims department to your shop without adding payroll."

Shop ManagerLong Island, NY
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

"The free review alone showed us almost four grand that we left on one file. We haven't handled the supplement calls since."

Shop ManagerLong Island, NY
$2โ€“3K basic estimate โ†’ $6โ€“7K final settlement What a typical fender-bender becomes once every operation is actually documented and priced right.

*Preview placeholders: replace with Amity's verified figures and client testimonials before launch.

Our Mission

Your Amicus in Every Claim.

Amity Appraisals claims team working in their New York City office
Amity Appraisals adjuster inspecting vehicle damage at a body shop

In law, an amicus curiae is a "friend of the court," not a party to the dispute, but a licensed expert permitted to step in, present the evidence, and make sure the decision reflects what's actually fair. Repair facilities face that same imbalance every time a claim is filed: the carrier has a department of adjusters and the expertise to protect their number. Your shop has an estimate and a phone that rings on hold.

Amity steps in as your amicus: a licensed claims advocate, not a vendor, not a litigant, but a knowledgeable ally who knows the process, speaks the language, and is authorized to represent your interest from the initial claim filing to the final approval. Our mission is to even those odds for every repair facility across the NYC Tristate. When you work with Amity, you're adding a claims department to your shop, one that only gets paid when you do.

Amity AppraisalsYour Ally in Every Settlement ยท NYC Tristate
Questions Shops Ask

Straight Answers

Nothing upfront. Our fee is a percentage of what we recover. If we don't move the number, you owe nothing. And if the carrier already paid you fairly, we'll tell you that too.

Yes: that's exactly what licensed claims adjusters are authorized to do: represent the policyholder's side with every insurance company. Licensing details are available on request.

The opposite. Properly documented estimates get approved faster because there's nothing left to argue about, and faster approvals mean cars stop sitting in your bays.

Let's talk about your mix. Many shops start by sending us their non-DRP work first and expand from there once they see the difference.

The estimate, photos, and claim info. Text them to (917) 510-4350 or send them by email, and we take it from there. Five minutes, start to finish.

Your Ally in Every Settlement

Send us one recent claim file. We'll show you, free and line by line, what was left on the table. No obligation, no fee unless we recover money for you.

Or call/text us directly: (917) 510-4350 ยท [email protected]

Free Damage Estimate

Tell Us About the Claim

Five quick fields and we take it from there. Your request goes straight to Amity by email and text.

Please enter your shop or facility name.
Please enter the vehicle year, make, and model.
Please enter a phone number.
Please enter a valid email address.
Your email app just opened with the request addressed to Amity. Tap here to also text it to (917) 510-4350.
Call Us Text an Estimate